Tuesday, August 23, 2005

Movies on Mafioso

Well, Mangal Pandey was the disappointment of the year. Took 4 years to make such shit. But its a waste of time to talk about such movies.

What I wanted to talk was about the theme of a different genre of movies. Movies which involved the Mafia. Well, I was watching Godfather the other day @ Pushkar's house and then watched Sarkar. Also, reminisced the first gangster movie - Satya and the followup of Company.

What struck me was the gradual delineation of boundary between bad and good.

If you observe Godfather - in all the 3 parts it firmly believed that what the Don did was bad and Michael and the Don himself were always trying to become 'legitimate'. Even when they mentioned about the days in Italy where they had to fight the government, it was a robinhood kind of thing to do but ultimately it was bad. Although, it was all about business and the family, however the family grudgingly accepted the business. Michael did not want to be part of it and Kay left Michael for what he became.

Satya - Here the family had very little say even though Bhiku Mahtre the protagonist loved his wife. Here, Satya joins initially to take revenge but the ultimately, he is in for the money.

Company is where the shades start becoming gray. Chandu's wife and mother have no qualms about him earning money by killing guys. And the movie does not show a robinhood kind of saga but its money and greed for which Chandu does not follow the path of good. A far cry from 'Mother India' where the mother does not tolerate such behavior.

However, Sarkar is where the protagonist is now good instead of being bad and he punishes the people since the justice system could not do its work. I do wonder how did the justice system degrade if not for such warlords if I may say. So if not a single innocent man is harmed by Sarkar who runs a parallel government than it means the laws are ineffective or the laws are not taken in the spirit in which they are to be enforced.

Now, why does the bad really become good. Is it the law as Ayn Rand mentions in Atlas Shrugged - Making a law which people are forced to break will involve more power to the government. But I do wonder, if the entire constitution is bad ...

This does not look to be the case then, the people involved do discharge their duties properly. Which of the above actually is what has happened ? Which means the sense of fairness and morality of people have nosedived in the society ..

Basically, the movies represent the genre of our own society or is it all fiction ...

Is RobinHood really a good person or are Robinhoods created due to the societies righteousness dives down ..

Any Thoughts !!!

8 comments:

अनूप said...

Though nothing can be termed right or wrong I think that circumstances force Vito Corleone to kill Don fanucci, circumstances force Satya to shoot the hotel owner who treats him in the worst possible way.But the same cannot be said about Chandu and Sarkar for that matter.They choose their paths of violence rather consciously and for their own benifits.Indian audience have this tendency to subconsciously forgive the protagonist of a movie no matter whether the path he follows is morally right or outright wrong. Hence Sarkar and Chandu stand out as heroes even though they deserve to be incarcerated and whipped.Robinhoods are people who want to do good to the society but the paths which they follow are questionable and definitely not 100% right.I woudnt say that the sense of fairness and morality has plummeted to all time lows, but exploitation of loopholes in the law and people utilizing it for their own benifits leads to a new Robinhood who raises his voice against these society's sharks albeit with inappropriate means

Balls said...

Really good blog Kausum...well researched and documented. Continuing from where u left I wud like to extended my thoughts on to another movie carrying the same message..Nayakan. It somewhat borders between Company and Godfather in the sense that initially Velu Nayakan (Kamal) chooses to kill first and avenge his dad's death and then plunge into becoming a Robinhood...even though his deeds to become Robinhood arent anywhere close to be accepted by society. He captures trades in drugs to garner money to help the needy instead of robbing the rich to fecilitate a good life for the poor. The answer to your question of whether Robinhood is good or bad depends on which side of the spectrum u really r in.

Anonymous said...

Deep man!

One thing though, as aup pointed out, we can perhaps not define right or wrong. Killing for example is bad, however, a soldier is expected to do it (good)! What dichotomy :-(. Neways, I guess beyond certain really pardonable circumstances, it is just a matter of convenience for us, for as Balls pointed out, it depends on the side of spectrum. But, is spectrum really the end of it, how far are we willing to stretch the spectrum to suit us?

Kausum said...

Aup said we cannot define right or wrong .. and it really depends on which side of the spectrum on is in ...

But the question is What is the spectrum ? Who or What defines the spectrum?

Am i not correct in assuming we define the right or wrong in the spectrum. So isnt the spectrum different for every individual ?

Anonymous said...

I think that Aup has hit the nail on the head. The Godfather, Sarkar, Company, Goodfellas etc. place gangsters on a pedestel. Holding a gun to someone's head and asking them to sign over a contract for a measly sum is not something thats right. Nevertheless, we love it, because its cool. It shows us how these people refuse to identify with the laws defined for them and live their life on the rules they define. This is what attracts us to these movies and the characters in these movies.

In my view Robin Hood, taken in the essence 'Robbing From the Rich and giving to the poor' - is not at all right in any sense. Who is Robin Hood to decide that the rich have enough money and they must be parted with it. Its My Money and I deserve it.

Following the 'Spectrum' point of view I think that we cannot just say that a spectrum is different for different people and let it be at that. Society, doesnt matter where, has certain Mores that must be followed. We can always place conditions and talk about needing someone who will operate beyond the law to get justice for the people, but the fact of the matter is that life operates on the 'Unequal Injustice for All' principle. lol. There is a probabilty that any one of us will suffer a horrible injustice that that is no reason for 'Protectors' to pop up all over the place.

Anonymous said...

glory hole nika @X@ hj download @X@ handjob links cynthia @X@ hollywood bigboobs @X@ julia parton movie @X@ ejactulations sophie @X@ squirt xxx may @X@ gushers galleries @X@ voyeur escuelas df @X@ osos peludos desnudos @X@ sin tetas @X@ maduros colombianos desnudos @X@ sasha travesti @X@ agujero europa famoso @X@ girls sqrting on @X@ ejaculating bambi @X@ handjob heaven bianca @X@ stroke job cynthia @X@ japanese handjobs angela @X@ anose prywatne @X@ galerie malolaty @X@ free niemkimodelki @X@

Anonymous said...

http://hometown.aol.com/young15500116/classroom-sex-stories-porn.htm
[url=http://hometown.aol.com/young15500116/classroom-sex-stories-porn.htm]classroom sex stories porn[/url]
classroom sex stories porn
http://hometown.aol.com/girls983701780/my-husband-is-addicted-to-writing-porn-stories.htm
[url=http://hometown.aol.com/girls983701780/my-husband-is-addicted-to-writing-porn-stories.htm]my husband is addicted to writing porn stories[/url]
my husband is addicted to writing porn stories
http://hometown.aol.com/girls983701780/how-to-make-love-and-sex-with-69.htm
[url=http://hometown.aol.com/girls983701780/how-to-make-love-and-sex-with-69.htm]how to make love and sex with 69[/url]
how to make love and sex with 69
http://hometown.aol.com/hard726554141/porn-babysitter-stories.htm
[url=http://hometown.aol.com/hard726554141/porn-babysitter-stories.htm]porn babysitter stories[/url]
porn babysitter stories
http://hometown.aol.com/girls983701780/farscape-porn-stories.htm
[url=http://hometown.aol.com/girls983701780/farscape-porn-stories.htm]farscape porn stories[/url]
farscape porn stories
http://hometown.aol.com/couple062513565/best-lesbo-sex-videos.htm
[url=http://hometown.aol.com/couple062513565/best-lesbo-sex-videos.htm]best lesbo sex videos[/url]
best lesbo sex videos
http://hometown.aol.com/girls983701780/olsen-twins-lesbian-porn-stories.htm
[url=http://hometown.aol.com/girls983701780/olsen-twins-lesbian-porn-stories.htm]olsen twins lesbian porn stories[/url]
olsen twins lesbian porn stories
http://hometown.aol.com/girls983701780/xxx-lesbian-porn-stories.htm
[url=http://hometown.aol.com/girls983701780/xxx-lesbian-porn-stories.htm]xxx lesbian porn stories[/url]
xxx lesbian porn stories
http://hometown.aol.com/hard726554141/spiritual-stories-of-people-with-porn-addictions.htm
[url=http://hometown.aol.com/hard726554141/spiritual-stories-of-people-with-porn-addictions.htm]spiritual stories of people with porn addictions[/url]
spiritual stories of people with porn addictions
http://hometown.aol.com/girls983701780/teacherstudent-erotic-porn-stories.htm
[url=http://hometown.aol.com/girls983701780/teacherstudent-erotic-porn-stories.htm]teacherstudent erotic porn stories[/url]
teacherstudent erotic porn stories

Anonymous said...

3d lesbo sex

Abhi picture baaki hai mere dost !

Freaks Inc.. Bengaluru.. 15 years 2 months and 8 days later.. Agenda for the meeting: Day 1 1. Paying our respects to the beginning of time ...